A published methodology for assessing green claims.

SPK GCMS3001:2026 sets out how Speeki assesses each environmental claim and issues a Speeki GreenDesk® determination, so anyone can see what was assessed and why.

Why we published it

Determinations you can examine

An internal methodology would have produced determinations that clients and regulators had to accept on trust. That is not good enough for a service built on independence.

A determination issued under a published, versioned standard can be examined. A regulator, a procurement team, a board or a court can read SPK GCMS3001:2026 and see what Speeki assessed, against which requirement, with which method and why it reached its conclusion. That is what makes the determination defensible to everyone who relies on it.

Every claim assessed through Speeki GreenDesk® is evaluated against a defined, published set of guidelines. Not internal judgement, not proprietary scoring and not a checklist assembled for the purpose.

Scott LaneCEO, founder and lead auditor

What it draws on

Three sources, one methodology

ISO standards

The technical baseline for every assessment.

  • ISO 14021:2016, self-declared environmental claims, incorporated in full
  • ISO 14020:2022, the principles for all environmental statements
  • ISO 14067:2018, the method behind carbon footprint, carbon neutral and net zero claims

Laws and regulations

The rules of every market where the claim will appear.

  • EU EmpCo Directive, applying from 27 September 2026
  • UK DMCCA and CMA Green Claims Code
  • US FTC Green Guides and California SB 343
  • Australian Consumer Law, and the rules of Singapore, Canada and Hong Kong

Analogous fields

Pharmaceutical and food health claims have required substantiation before publication for decades.

  • Net impression: what a reasonable consumer understands, not what the advertiser intended
  • Competent and reliable evidence, as applied by the FTC and the NAD
  • Fifty years of FTC, NAD, ASA and EFSA practice

The assessment

Six stages, every claim

Each claim submitted to Speeki GreenDesk® goes through the same six stages, prepared by Nicole® and reviewed by a Speeki expert.

  1. Claim classification

    The claim type, its ISO 14021:2016 category and the rules of every market where it will appear.

  2. Net impression

    What a reasonable consumer in the target market would understand, including imagery, context and anything left out.

  3. ISO 14021:2016 review

    The claim checked against every applicable clause of the standard.

  4. Evidence quality

    Whether the evidence is competent and reliable, produced by qualified experts, current and specific to the product as sold.

  5. Disclaimer adequacy

    Whether a qualifier actually corrects the headline claim, or only adds small print most consumers never read.

  6. Regulatory compliance

    Every jurisdiction in scope, including absolute prohibitions that apply regardless of the evidence.

A Speeki expert then reviews the full assessment file and signs the determination, citing the standard, clause or rule behind every finding.

The outcome

What the determination means

Green

The claim holds up

It conforms to ISO 14021:2016 and SPK GCMS3001:2026, complies with the rules of every market in scope, creates no misleading net impression and rests on competent, reliable, current evidence specific to the product.

Amber

It can, with changes

The claim would be Green if specified changes are made. Every change is stated precisely, with the provision it must satisfy.

Red

It does not hold up

The claim as submitted is non-compliant. Every ground is stated, citing the clause, rule or doctrine, so you know exactly where you stand and what your options are.

No determination is issued by Nicole® alone. The signed determination can be referenced in regulatory submissions, procurement responses, board reporting and investor communications.

Beyond ISO 14021:2016

Why ISO 14021:2016 was not enough

ISO 14021:2016 is the right foundation and is incorporated in full. It defines what environmental claims must demonstrate. It was not designed for an independent, pre-publication assessment of a specific claim, in a specific market, for a specific audience.

Following it alone would have left the most important question unanswered: what does this claim actually communicate, and is that accurate?

  1. How to determine what a claim communicates to a reasonable consumer, the net impression standard of advertising law.
  2. What makes evidence adequate in quality, not merely present: the competent and reliable standard.
  3. Implied claims, conveyed through imagery, context or overall presentation rather than words.
  4. The rules of each market, including the absolute prohibitions of EU Directive 2024/825.
  5. The assessment sequence, the determination criteria and what the determination must contain.

The ISO framework

Governing the body and the method

ISO/IEC 17029:2019 sets how an independent validation and verification body must operate. It governs the body, not the methodology.

It covers independence, impartiality, competence and record keeping, and SPK GCMS3001:2026 is designed in accordance with it. ISO 14020:2022 sets general principles for environmental statements, but neither standard provides a claim-level assessment method.

SPK GCMS3001:2026 fills that gap: ISO 14021:2016 as the technical baseline, ISO/IEC 17029:2019 as the governance framework, the regulatory instruments of each major market, and the advertising law method developed over fifty years of independent pre-publication review.

Not a departure from the ISO framework. The ISO framework, made operational.

Put your claims through SPK GCMS3001:2026

Speeki GreenDesk® applies this methodology to every claim you submit, with a signed Green, Amber or Red determination. No obligation. No sales pitch.

About Speeki GreenDesk®

Talk to Nicole®

Speeki GreenDesk®

Start chatting